Round 1 - 14/09/1935
Thornton Hibs 4 Denbeath Star 0
[J.Sharp 2, J.Wilson 2]
Team - Stevenson; Stoddart, Easson; Syme, Scott, Wilkie; Law, Murray, Sharp, Dewar, Wilson

Round 2 - 12/10/1935
Whitburn 3 Thornton Hibs 3
[J.Sharp 2, W.Wardlaw]
Team - Stevenson; Stoddart, Easson; Wilkie, Scott, Harley; Syme, Murray, Sharp, Dewar, Wardlaw

Round 2 Replay - 19/10/1935
Thornton Hibs 1 Whitburn 4
[J.Murray]
Team - Stevenson; Stoddart, Easson; Wilkie, Scott, Harley; Syme, Murray, Sharp, Dewar, Wardlaw

1936/37

Round 1 - 12/09/1936
Crossgates Primrose 3 Thornton Hibs 0

1937/38

Round 1 - 11/09/1937
Thornton Hibs 4 Rosslyn 3
[Wyles 3, Harley]
Team - Stevenson; Blyth, Fraser; Syme, Wyness, Harley; Wyles, Murray, McKinlay, Sneddon, Wardlaw.

Round 2 - 09/10/1937
Thornton Hibs 2 Thorntree United 0
[W.Wardlaw, Hamilton]
Team - Stevenson; McKinlay, Fraser; Syme, Wyness, Harley; Hamilton, Murray, Wyles, Sneddon, Wardlaw.

Round 3 - 13/11/1937
Stoneyburn 4 Thornton Hibs 1
[Wyles]
Team - Stevenson; McKinlay, Fraser; Syme, Wyness, Harley; Hamilton, Murray, Wyles, Sneddon, Wardlaw.

1938/39

Round 1 - 10/09/1938
Thornton Hibs 3 Dunnikier Colliery 4
[Crawford 2, Hyndman]

1939/40

Round 1 - 02/09/1939
Thornton Hibs 3 Blairhall Colliery 2
[Stewart 2, Wilson]

Because of the outbreak of War, the Hibs withdrew from the tournament