1995/96 - Robert Gardiner (8)
1996/97 - Andy Grant (21)
1997/98 - Neil Sellars (17)
1998/99 - Neil Sellars (19)
1999/00 - Graeme Walker (22)
2000/01 - Graeme Dursley (21)
2001/02 - Neil Sellars (16)
2002/03 - Graeme Dursley (14)
2003/04 - Mikey Cunningham (12)
2004/05 - John Shields (10)
2005/06 - Darren Duffy/Alan McAllister (6)
2006/07 - Gary Gilfillan (11)
2007/08 - Graeme Dursley/Mikey Cunningham (13)
2008/09 - Alan McAllister (12)
2009/10 - Ross Morgan (20)
2010/11 - Coco Mullen (9)
2011/12 - Lee White/Adam Drummond (15)
2012/13 - Adam Drummond (13)
2013/14 - Garry Thomson (24)
2014/15 - Chris Ireland (27)
2015/16 - Chris Ireland (13)
2016/17 - Garry Thomson (31)
2017/18 - Garry Thomson (20)
2018/19 - Garry Thomson (34)
2019/20 - No award
2020/21 - No award
2021/22 - Garry Thomson (21)
2022/23 - Joe Kinninmonth (22)